Best Anejo Tequila: Our Top 5 Picks

Tequila — the very word conjures up images of vibrant fiestas, sun-drenched beaches, and that unmistakable agave aroma.

In fact, tequila is more than just a drink. It’s an art form honed over generations, and within this storied spirit, anejo (añejo) tequila stands apart as the most refined expression.

This aged spirit, patiently matured in oak barrels, transcends the fiery reputation of its younger counterparts. It’s known for its symphony of complex flavors and a smooth, sophisticated drinking experience.

If you’re curious to delve into the world of tequila, you’ve come to the right place. In this guide, we’ll walk you through our top picks for the best anejo tequilas. From the smoky depths of aged agave to the velvety smoothness of well-rounded flavor profiles, prepare to indulge your senses and elevate your appreciation for the finer things in life.

What You Need to Know About Anejo Tequila

Raise your caballito glass with us as we embark on a journey through the agave-drenched landscapes of Mexico, where the story of Anejo Tequila unfolds in all its aged glory.

Anejo Tequila: The Best Tequila for Sipping

Añejo, the Spanish word for “aged,” perfectly encapsulates the essence of this distinguished liquor. Unlike its younger blanco and reposado counterparts, añejo undergoes a meticulous aging process in oak barrels, which gives it a depth of character, making it a true connoisseur’s delight.

Anejo tequila is made from the blue agave plant that flourishes in the volcanic soils of Mexico’s Jalisco region. When mature, the heart of the agave (called the piña) is harvested and slowly roasted. This brings out the plant’s rich, earthy sugars, which are then fermented and distilled into tequila.

Then, the resulting tequila blend is aged in oak barrels for at least one, but often two to three years. This extended aging journey is what gives anejo its distinct complexity. As it ages in the barrel, the agave essence mingles with notes of vanilla, caramel, and smoke from the oak. The finished spirit has a warm golden hue and a smooth, velvety taste.

While younger tequilas shine in cocktails, sipping an anejo neat or on the rocks is the preferred way to experience its nuances. Let it breathe and open up much like a fine scotch or cognac. Depending on the brand and age, its layered flavors invite contemplation – one might detect cinnamon, chocolate, dried fruit, and buttery toffee.

How to Choose the Best Tequila Anejo?

Choosing the perfect anejo tequila is an art form that requires a discerning palate and an understanding of the key factors contributing to its quality and character. Here’s a guide to help you navigate the vast options and select the best anejo tequila that suits your taste and preferences.

When evaluating anejo tequilas, the first consideration is age. To legally qualify as an anejo, the spirit must be aged a minimum of one year in oak barrels, but the extra time often results in increased complexity and refinement. Look for tequilas aged 2-3 years for optimal smoothness and flavor integration.

Next, examine the color. A quality anejo will take on warm golden and copper hues from its time in barrels. Be wary of tequilas that appear overly light or dark, which may indicate artificial coloring. Also, check for legs, or viscosity, when you swirl it — the oilier and more slowly it runs down the glass, the richer the mouthfeel.

Now for the exciting part — think about the flavor profile you prefer. Do you enjoy rich caramel notes with a hint of spice, or are you drawn to smoother, more subtle flavors? Sampling different brands and expressions can help you identify your preferences and narrow your options.

Consider your budget, as anejo tequilas range in price. While some bottles may come with a higher price tag, plenty of affordable options offer excellent quality and flavor. Decide how much you’re willing to spend and explore options within your price range to find the best value for your money.

Above all, don’t hesitate to consult knowledgeable liquor store staff or bartenders. They can offer valuable insights and recommendations based on your preferences and budget. Additionally, online resources and reviews can provide further guidance as you navigate the world of anejo tequila.

What Does Anejo Tequila Cost?

When it comes to anejo tequila (or any liquor, for that matter), you generally get what you pay for. Prices vary widely based on state taxes and local duties, brand, age, production process, and prestige. For a standard 750ml bottle, you can expect to pay $40-$100 for a decent anejo, while premium options range from $100-$200. Top-shelf extra anejos and limited editions can cost over $200 per bottle.

If you’re dining out, a 1.5oz glass of anejo tequila at the bar or restaurant starts around $10-$15 for a mid-range brand. Top-shelf pours can cost $20 or more per serving depending on the establishment, given that bars substantially markup liquor prices.

While sipping well-crafted anejo may be considered a luxury, devotees of fine tequila argue the experience is well worth the price. Swirling and savoring premium anejo tequila offers an exploration of flavors and craftsmanship that cannot be replicated. After all, life’s joys sometimes come with a higher price tag.

Where Can You Buy Anejo Tequila?

Anejo tequilas are super popular and always in demand. Hence, they’re easily available. You can find various options in liquor stores, online stores, and on menus at bars and restaurants.

Most well-stocked liquor stores will carry a range of anejo tequilas. Look for retailers with a robust selection of tequilas and mezcals, as they often have knowledgeable staff who can guide you. Some exclusive boutique stores may even offer rare, limited-edition aged tequilas.

Upscale Mexican restaurants and lively cantinas typically stock several anejo varieties to showcase in their craft cocktails and tasting flights. You may also find aged tequilas at specialized wine and spirits bars – any establishment focusing on nuanced sipping spirits rather than high-volume drinking.

Of course, you can always order premium anejo tequila online and conveniently deliver it to your door. Online platforms like Speakeasy Co allow you to peruse ratings and reviews while building your customized spirits selection. There’s no need to hunt down that hard-to-find extra anejo when you can click and sip.

The thrill of the hunt is part of the fun of collecting exceptional tequilas. Talk to local bartenders and shop owners to get the inside scoop on where to find their latest rare acquisitions. And if you can't find this tequila, you can always choose an alternative like Reposado tequila.

The Best Anejo Tequila Brands

We’ve covered everything from the history of anejo tequila to how to taste and buy it. Now comes the exciting part — revealing our picks for the top shelf, the five best anejo tequilas that deserve a place of honor in your collection.

1. JFC Anejo Tequila

• MSRP: $157.99
• Proof: 80 (40% ABV)
• Tasting Notes: Toasty Coconut, Lemon Curd, Oak.
• Our Rating: 5/5

JFC Anejo Tequila stands out as a top contender in the world of anejo tequilas, offering a luxurious drinking experience that combines sophistication with bold flavors. Its sweet and toasty coconut and lemon curd notes, complemented by delicate hints of white flowers and oak, create a sensory journey that captivates the palate.

Pros:

• A unique flavor profile combines sweet and toasty notes with hints of oak.
• Smooth and balanced, making it easy to sip and enjoy.
• Meticulously aged to perfection, ensuring a high-quality drinking experience.
• Long-lasting taste that lingers on the palate, inviting you to savor every moment.

Cons:

• The complex taste may appeal to only some palates.
• Higher price point compared to other anejo tequilas on the market.

2. PATRÓN Añejo Tequila

• MSRP: $61.99
• Proof: 80 (40% ABV)
• Tasting Notes: Vanilla, Raisin, Honey, Black Pepper, Sandalwood.
• Our Rating: 4/5

Patrón Añejo is an excellent introductory aged tequila, offering sweet and smooth flavors at an affordable price. It tastes sweeter and lighter than more complex extra añejos – think honeyed agave flavors mixed with raisin and black pepper. The finish is smooth and easy-drinking with subtle oak influence. It’s handcrafted from 100% Weber blue agave in Jalisco, Mexico, and aged 12+ months in a blend of oak barrels. 

Pros:

• Affordable price for an aged tequila, making it accessible to a wide range of consumers.
• Sweet, smooth, and easy-drinking, perfect for sipping neat or mixing in cocktails.
• A versatile flavor profile that complements a variety of cocktail recipes.
• It’s a recognized premium brand known for its quality and craftsmanship.

Cons:

• Lacks the complexity of higher-end añejo tequilas.
• The finish could be longer and warmer.

3. Goza Tequila

• MSRP: $57.99
• Proof: 80 (40% ABV)
• Tasting Notes: Vanilla, Caramel, Spice, Honey, Cinnamon.
• Our Rating: 4/5 

Goza’s hand-selected single-barrel anejo tequila offers an exquisite drinking experience worth savoring. This award-winning liquor — handcrafted from 100% authentic blue agave — is aged in white-oak whiskey barrels for up to 18 months. The result is a complex and nuanced flavor with hints of vanilla, caramel, and a touch of spice. It’s perfect for sipping neat, as the flavors unfold slowly and elegantly with each sip. 

Pros:

• It has an intriguing flavor profile that combines sweet and spicy notes.
• Smooth and complex, perfect for sipping neat or in cocktails.
• Full-bodied flavor with a sweet finish that satisfies the palate.
• The lingering aroma enhances the overall drinking experience.
• Excellent price point for the quality and craftsmanship offered.

Cons:

• Difficult to find due to high demand.
• The sweet finish may appeal to only some palates, particularly those who prefer drier spirits.

4. Don Julio 1942

• MSRP: $179.99
• Proof: 80 (40% ABV)
• Tasting Notes: Butterscotch, Mint, White Pepper, Cinnamon.
• Our Rating: 4/5

A timeless masterpiece in the world of anejo tequilas, Don Julio 1942 presents a refined and elegant flavor profile. Named in honor of the year that Don Julio Gonzalez began his Tequila-making journey, this expression pays homage to his legacy with every sip. The finish is long and lingering, leaving a warm and satisfying impression. It’s an exceptional occasion-tequila worthy of its iconic status.

Pros:

• It has a balanced flavor profile that delights the senses with every sip.
• It’s incredibly smooth from start to finish, making it a pleasure to drink.
• Iconic reputation and premium presentation, worthy of special occasions.
• The smooth and luxurious texture elevates the drinking experience.

Cons:

• Higher price point compared to other anejo tequilas on the market.
• It may not be suitable for everyday use for some consumers.

5. Nosotros Madera (Cider Barrel Limited Edition)

• MSRP: $341.99
• Proof: 80 (40% ABV)
• Tasting Notes: Dried Fruits, Spice, Vanilla, Sandalwood.
• Our Rating: 4/5

Nosotros Madera Tequila Añejo sets itself apart with its innovative aging process in wet cider barrels, resulting in a unique flavor profile that appeals to whiskey lovers and tequila enthusiasts alike. Aged for 20 months in barrels previously used to age 2 Towns Ciderhouse’ Bad Apple’ batch and Woodford Reserve Bourbon whiskey, this limited edition tequila offers a sensory experience like no other.

Pros:

• The unique aging process in wet cider barrels adds depth and complexity.
• Fantastic taste and finish that lingers on the palate.
• Smooth, rich, and complex notes that captivate the senses.
• It’s highly sought after as a limited edition release.

Cons

• The higher price point may be prohibitive for some consumers (but the quality and craftsmanship justify the investment.)
• It isn’t easy to find because of its rarity.

Indulge Your Senses with Anejo Tequila

With their sophisticated flavors and velvety smoothness, anejos offer a rewarding sipping experience that will expand your tequila horizons.

Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or just developing an appreciation, keep exploring the diverse offerings of aged tequilas. Let the mellow notes of vanilla, baked agave, and spice indulge your palate. Sip slowly and contemplate, allowing the flavors to blossom and unfold across your senses.

So, raise your glass to the magic of añejo tequila. May it ignite your senses, tantalize your taste buds, and leave you yearning for more.